Top 3 Places To Get Tomato Pie in Utica

Utica, New York, is a city known for its rich culinary heritage, and at the heart of its food scene lies the irresistible tomato pie. In this blog post, we'll take you on a journey through three renowned establishments—Roma Sausage & Deli, Holland Farms, and Napoli's Italian Bakery & Deli—that have mastered the art of creating mouthwatering tomato pies. From secret family recipes to traditional baking techniques, each place offers a unique and unforgettable experience for both locals and visitors seeking an authentic taste of Utica's Italian flavors.


Utica Tomato Pie


Roma Sausage & Deli: With a history spanning several decades, Roma Sausage & Deli has become synonymous with authentic Italian flavors and high-quality products. Their tomato pie is a culinary masterpiece that captures the essence of Italian cuisine. The thin and crispy crust provides the perfect foundation for the star of the dish: a rich and flavorful tomato sauce. What sets Roma's tomato pie apart is their secret family recipe, striking the perfect balance of sweetness and tanginess, achieved by simmering fresh tomatoes and aromatic herbs and spices. Topped with melted grated cheese, this pie is a truly irresistible treat.

Danielle's Tomato Pie: Another noteworthy addition to Utica's tomato pie scene is Danielle's Tomato Pie. This hidden gem has been quietly making waves among locals and those in the know. While not as widely known as the other establishments mentioned, Danielle's Tomato Pie offers a unique twist on this beloved dish.

What sets Danielle's Tomato Pie apart is their innovative approach to flavors and ingredients. Their tomato pie showcases a creative blend of traditional Italian elements with modern culinary techniques. The crust, although thin and crispy like the others, has a unique texture that adds an extra layer of delight to each bite.

The star of Danielle's Tomato Pie is the tomato sauce, which features a delightful balance of tanginess and robust flavors. Their secret recipe incorporates a selection of locally sourced tomatoes, ensuring freshness and quality. This sauce is the perfect companion to the perfectly baked crust, resulting in a symphony of taste and texture.

At Danielle's, they also offer a variety of toppings and add-ons, allowing customers to customize their tomato pie experience. From fresh basil and oregano to premium cheeses and even gourmet meats, there's no shortage of options to satisfy any palate.

While Danielle's Tomato Pie may be a newer addition to the Utica scene, it has quickly gained a reputation for its unique take on this traditional dish. The passion and dedication of the team behind Danielle's shine through in every pie they create, making it a worthy contender in the city's tomato pie landscape.

Napoli's Italian Bakery & Deli: Napoli's is another must-visit destination in Utica for those seeking exceptional tomato pie. The bakery's dedication to simplicity and high-quality ingredients shines through in their creation. The thin and crispy crust serves as a canvas for the flavorful tomato sauce, crafted with a harmonious blend of tomatoes, herbs, and spices. Locally sourced ingredients and traditional baking methods ensure each bite bursts with vibrant flavors. Napoli's Italian Bakery & Deli is a treasure trove of Italian delights, offering an array of pastries, bread, and deli items, all made with passion and attention to detail.

Utica Halfmoon Shirt


Honorable mention: Holland Farms: Established in 1955, Holland Farms is a renowned bakery that has been delighting Utica residents and visitors with its delectable tomato pie. Their commitment to using high-quality ingredients and traditional baking techniques sets them apart. The flaky, buttery crust pairs harmoniously with the vibrant and tangy tomato sauce, while the sprinkling of grated cheese adds a touch of richness. Generous portions and a dedication to quality make Holland Farms a beloved institution in Utica's culinary scene.

Halfmoon Shirt Utica Ny

Utica, New York, is a tomato pie lover's paradise, and these three establishments—Roma Sausage & Deli, Holland Farms, and Napoli's Italian Bakery & Deli—offer a journey through the city's rich culinary heritage. Whether you're craving a secret family recipe, a dedication to traditional baking, or a taste of simplicity and authenticity, these places have something to offer. Each bite of their tomato pies transports you to Italy, showcasing the flavors that have made them beloved institutions in Utica. So, next time you find yourself in the city, be sure to indulge in these delightful creations and experience the magic of Utica's tomato pie scene.

Utica New York

1 comment

  • In the 60’s UFA had superb pie.

    Stuart Levin

Leave a comment

Please note, comments must be approved before they are published